i saw hamelin perform both of them like 4 years ago and he performed it very well. but i gotta agree with da jred somewhat. its not the greatest concerto ever written by any means at all. i could name tons of concertos that are better from it from that time period, such as the prok concertos.
I’m not saying it’s the pinnacle of the concerto literature… I’m just saying it’s FAR from a ‘sheeyat’ piece. Maybe you guys are taking it a bit too seriously. It is not a profound work, just a witty, freewheeling example of Shostakovich’s early style.
but Shostakovich’s early style: The Nose, Lady Macbeth, is so full of creativity and vigor and ballsy youthful audacity. Works like this concerto, which come from slightly later, exhibit everything I just cannot appreciate about shostakovich, especially its general cheesiness
i would say that i think there are other works with humor and “cuteness” that are much greater in the literature…
i readily admit that i almost never like shostakovich’s music though (except for the string quartets), so it could just be my prejudice
i love the 1st sonata. i would love to learn it but it looks like an all around bitch of a piece. its a great example of shosty’s early style, along with the operas that jred mentioned.