The annual favourite pianists thread

Man I have the most anti-sdc list ever. I dun know exactly what it is I doubt it would get approval (if I looked for it :dong:)

Go look for it! I remember Lupu and Curzon, who are both admirable picks IMO.

Hehe. Unless it was clear I meant go look for the list, not go look for approval.

I’m here today… but not really here.

ergh, to be honest I don’t even think I have 10. I listen to more orchestral stuff than anything else.

So probs
Zim
Lupu
Perahia
Curzon
Solomon
Cortot
Rach
Schiff

The rest would be amazing for particular rep like Kocsis - Bartok (even though I have a love/hate thing with Bartok) and Casadesus - Ravel, Katchen - Brahms.

1 Like

I’ve kept silent in this thread as well… not because I don’t have 10, but because I have 40. I can name the first 5-6 relatively securely, but from then on it’d be dice rolling essentially.

10 is an arbitrary number, that number stopped me from making a list actually! Name your 5-6

I can imagine you ranking them differently at different periods in their life so you’d probs end up with the same pianist 3 times haha

ZIFF
HO
WIBI
MAXIM
LOLA
DONGAH
YUJA
HJ LIM
PUNANI
TRUMOFO
BZCHOLAH

n tru da body iz a complete zentence :sunglasses:

1 Like

Like so ->

  1. Richter
  2. Horowitz
  3. Sokolov
  4. Pogorelich
  5. de Larrocha
  6. Pletnev

I wasn’t here 11 years ago of course, but what I can say in comparison is that since then Michelangeli, Hamelin, Fiorentino and Zimerman have dropped in rank, while Sokolov, Cziffra, Hofmann and Leschenko have risen (indeed, 11 years ago I couldn’t stand Leschenko’s playing!).

Yes I mean… really! You can also put it together in so many different ways and under different premises. I’m as interested in the artistic side of music as in that relating solely to interpretation, so in the above I also have to ask myself questions akin to whether this guy is a better rapper than that guy is a metal guitarist. They do two completely different things in music, I don’t find them directly comparable.

I request to be placed between da PUNANI n da LOLA so dat at least sum of deir hype can rub off on me

:sunglasses:

Or at least Lola’s dong :sunglasses:

Also, da CHIN (Trimofo) iz not on da zepp list? I c…

HAHAHAHAHA ok! :sunglasses:

alzo if da DONGAH iz truly out of cummizzion i vil replace him wiz da MENACE, bazically da zame mofo :sunglasses:

1 Like

Hahaha

Da menace can actually get a massive forte.

With Dongah, hiz acrobatics n facials only giff da impression of a tru forte :sunglasses:

ahahaha lyk da ZLIT, da DONGAH haff inzane zentimental value fo da zepp. da zepp bazically learned all hiz ‘tech’ from watchin deze 2 legendz :sunglasses:

1 Like
  1. Liberace
  2. Clayderman
  3. Lang Lang’s father
1 Like

Interesting…