It occurs to me that my top 10 has undergone some changes - so maybe, being the new year and all, it’s time for us to make some new lists.
My 10 favourite pianists:
1 Richter
2 Gilels
3 Gieseking
4 Rubinstein
5 Solomon
6 Kapell
7 Fiorentino
8 A. Fischer
9 Freire
10 Arrau
As you can see, Gieseking has made his way up into the top 3, even though he wasn’t even in my top 10 last year. Solomon as well has made huge gains, while Horowitz has fallen off the list entirely.
VOLODYA
January 12, 2008, 12:30am
2
haha damn
1 HO/Richter
3
4 ziff
5 Attwood
6 Orozco
7 Kapell
8 Ruby
9 Freire
10 tha CANDAIN 10/1
Pianists I listened to a lot more of this year and gained even more respect for:
Petri, Kapell, Bolet, Levy, Kapustin, Medtner, Orozco, Cherkassky
My absolute top favorite pianists:
Moiseiwitsch
Hofmann and Glenn Gould
Schnabel
Rachmaninoff
Horowitz
Richter
Note; I didn’t list people like Friedman, Rosenthal, Busoni and a bunch of other heroes due to the unfortunate paucity of their recordings
Hofmann
Fiorentino
Horowitz
Richter
Cziffra
Rachmaninoff
Rubinstein
Cortot
Arrau
Friedman
It starts to get 'in no particular order’ish after the top 4 which remains more or less unchanged since last yr. Gilels has dropped out
oh and solomon will surely make great gains in the coming yr, he has two of the 3 T’s that I look for 'tone and technique, not sure about temp yet, he can be rather dour. Fuck just realised I forgot Ginzburg, he is actually my 5th favourite.
I will do my best in the coming year to restore Gilels’ place on your top 10.
And I have hopes that the Live Solomon Brahms 1 I just ordered will be legendary, so that could bump him up a few points for you.
Im finally going to admit it (haha maybe to myself as well):
Glenn Gould is my favourite pianist.
and then ofcourse da standards follow:
Richter
Gilels
Annie Fischer
Sokolov
Freire
Zimerman
Arrau
Solomon
Keurti
but da G man stands alone for me
I have a VERY hard time working out a numeric ranking (since it’s often very subjective), but on this day, at this hour, etc., here’s my preference:
Gilels
Lupu (tie)
Zimerman
Rzewski (immensely under-appreciated as a pianist)
Aimard
Cziffra
Bolet
Richter
Michelangeli
Orozco
Other greats:
Claude Frank
Gould
Annie Fischer
De Larrocha
Orgy
Horowitz
yeah it is very subjective, there are probably 30 odd pianists that I couldn’t be without.
Tru.
This thread vud possibly be more interesting if it only included living people
1 Like
al1
January 12, 2008, 12:40pm
17
Top 3, divided by a gnat’s chuff:
Feinberg
Solomon
Richter
I can’t settle beyond those, so in no particular order, and with no guarantee that they’ll be there next week:
Mindru Katz
A. Fischer
Fiorentino
Sokolov
E. Fischer
Gilels
Kapell
In no particular order:
Gilels, Kapell, Cortot, Lipatti
Moiseiwitsch, Friedmann, Sofronitsky
1 Like
Thracozaag:
Moiseiwitsch
'bout damn time someone other than me gave benno zum due respect.