A bit ?
Need to see it in context.
DAYUM
zo
ticket refund cummah?
Iāve read that itās increasingly difficult for organisers to get her on stage. She wants to cancel a lot. So long as she doesnāt cancel her performance with Zilberstein which Iām supposed to attend, because I never claimed my refund when Pletnev cancelled last year, though Iād try to make the effort if it happened again.
āAudiences are not important for me now and they never were. I have reached a stage when now I am even more terrified of house concerts where the public is very near. If I have to play when they are close, then I am quite afraid. It happened to meā¦well, I was unwell and I was in California but I decided to play four-hands with a friend for his fatherās birthday. We prepared and I arrived there and there were crowds of people there for the birthday party. I was terrified. I went upstairs and slept for two hours and then I came down. There were four people left. And I said āNow I can playā. OK, I hadnāt been playing, Iād been ill ā but I was terrified"
Supposedly the whole quote. I gathered it had something to do with her stage fright. But itās still pretty disrespectful. Just record if you donāt want to play live.
Especially at her age, although she doesnāt seem to have diminished much technically. Even Friere is starting to sound a little ragged compared to how he was the first time I heard him in 2014.
Luckily Lupu is still in shape
I think heās played/playing several times here this season, but really heās like Pollini; thereās no reason to hear either of them anymore.
He plays here in a few weeks as well but Iāve reached the same conclusion, and will pass on the concert. I actually have enjoyed each concert Iāve attended with him in recent years, but itās just too crippled. Dude doesnāt even have tech to play a simple Schubert MM anymore, and if I complain about young pianists lacking a proper fortissimo Lupu barely even makes it above pianissimo.
I do regret missing Pollini in May though. I would have loved to be there simply for the CG value.
Argerich is not important for me and she never was.
Likewise. But I donāt like being cancelled on, so I hope she shows up on the 1st of April.
Sheās exciting, Iāve always enjoyed that. In my view YW is a little bit like her, just less exciting and less musical. If I want to have a good time, I listen to Argerich.
This is about me as well. Iāve heard her twice and both were very good. Itās just that sheās all fingers and instinct, what she does tends to go in through one ear and out through the other with me.
Depends on the rep for me, her PC2 is the best Iāve heard.
My impression is the opposite, vis-a-vis YW and Argerich. I donāt think Argerich has really reached me even once. It doesnāt help that sheās playing concerti most of the time, however.
Yeah they might need to be compared around the same age. For sure the concert / recording experience will differ. Personally I like that sheās mostly instinct (as X says). Thatās her strong suit and perhaps why so many have connected with her. I mean classical pianists in general donāt come across like that, and the ones who do at times, like Brand and Villa, are really thrilling (granted Brand et al had more to offer, but I mean about those moments when they really let go). How would Argerich sound if she tried to be more deliberate and musical? I donāt know, but again it reminds me of YW in how she went away from her strong suit (instincts) and tried to play Beethoven and Schumann.
The curious thing about Argerich, is that she makes a very strong impression on me as a woman; she has a super strong, magnetic personality, but for some reason this doesnāt come across at all for me in her playing, which is usually too impetuous for my taste. I guess you could point to this impetuousness as a sign of a strong personality, but itās not impetuousness linked with intensity, which for me is the true indicator of the sort of force of personality Iām interested in. As such, it often just comes across as a mad rush, as a kind of waywardness. A young (female) pianist from a similar mould is Buniatishvili, who also seems super charming in person (when she isnāt trying to come across as an intellectual), but whose playing is way too uncontrolled.
I had a friend in my teens who was a super fan and kept sending me recordings despite that I was rather ambivalent about them. I once asked him to explain what he liked so much about her, and then followed a long letter where the word āsexyā featured about 2000 times. =)
I have no particular opinion of her as a person, but I do think her musical personality is rather bitchy. Itās as if she doesnāt give a damn. I donāt think sheās pianistically careless, but I do think she is musically (and I think she got that from Gulda, who also comes across a bit like that).
haha damn now thatās an insult. To me oneās a talent, the other is just part of contemporary celebrity culture, which is a large part of DG as well.
Yeah thatās a good point, but I suppose it comes down to your own personality, as in how you respond to it. For example Iāve talked to people who donāt find Brand intense, and that just doesnāt make sense to me. Certain personalities just wonāt respond to others. Weāre all like that and it makes a market.
In my mind, sheās similar to Gould in that theyāre both phenomenal pianists but their ideas tend to grate. Her rubato can be so wayward and surging, it sounds drunk. She can be slapdash but also tender.
I think Iāve mentioned the only time Iāve heard her live was Prok 3 with Dutoit. I mehed at the program but at least itāll be exciting I thought. Nothing. No mad dash at the end, dead in time. Amazing fingers and reviews were all good of course but wasnāt energised which is the very least I would have thought from her. Andsnes of all people managed to raise my pulse at the end of rach 3!
As a person, Iāve always thought she was a bitch so that quote really doesnāt surprise me. I wonder why ABC put it up? Unless they wanted to stir up some cuntraversy?
Surging or searching?
Surging sounds like a positive, searching sounds aimless.