Medtner Zonataz Poll

  • 1 - F Minor op5
  • 2 - Ab Major op11no1
  • 3 - D Minor op11no2
  • 4 - C Major op11no3
  • 5 - G Minor op22
  • 6 - C Minor op25no1
  • 7 - E Minor op25no2
  • 8 - F# Major op27
  • 9 - A Minor op30
  • 10 - A Minor op38
  • 11 - C Minor op39
  • 12 - Bb Minor op53no1
  • 13 - F Minor op53no2
  • 14 - G Major op56

0 voters

1 Like

I haff not heard 1 Medtner zheeyat :nopazz:
I do have the op.5 muzic zumwhere.

2 Likes

I can say I love Medtner now. Back in the Noughties I bought Hamelin’s sonata set but couldn’t get into it. The narration / storytelling element in his work really appeals to me now.

1 Like

HAHAHA WTF

2 Likes

Ahahaha to moi da MED a one-zong cumpozah :sunglasses:

2 Likes

:doc::poop::zombie:

3 Likes

@iamcanadian wutz yo fav op30?

It wuz juzt edged out, an underrated one

One ov ma fav perfz ov it

1 Like

I luv da Op 39 tragica son

1 Like

I like his fairy tales most of all, TBH

1 Like

I’m surprised op. 39 shares the lead. I’ve neglected this so I know what I’m gonna listen to later :pill:

1 Like

It’s not really one of my favourite sonatas, but I like Nikonovich’s rec best.

1 Like

Hahah wtf it wuz one ov yo votez :lib:

Yep, I didn’t have my glasses on. Was aiming for Op. 38. :-/

Though to be fair, I love all of Medtner’s sonatas, so if we were allowed 14 votes I’d have used them all up.

4 Likes

Hahah I expected da Minaccioza to get mo love, tiz hiz mozt modern zounding piece, alwayz loved how alluring itz oddnezz iz

1 Like

This is a hard questions. The first one is really great

1 Like

I’m still waiting on a great rec of it. None of the recs I’ve heard quite does it for me.

I love them all really. The ones I chose maybe the most. Probably the sonatas I’ve listened to the most out of all composers.

1 Like

Juz not a cumposer I’ve gotten round to.
I think i followed through one of the cuncertoz ages ago.

I think the best place to start with Medtner might be opus 39 no 5 «Sonata Tragica». Nice themes, good melodies and great climaxes. Does @Da_Comme agree?

1 Like