https://www.pianostreet.com/smf/index.php?topic=22403.0
da 10/2 reply 
https://www.pianostreet.com/smf/index.php?topic=22307.0
and da firzt reply by da JAKE
Nope!
Do I want to hear it? 
1 Like
Haha tru if u can zumhow track it down
wuz on a random japaneze amateur 88 zite
He zet da 
fo da moz INZANE amacha 88 tech in hiztory
Pozzibly only rivalled by da Wee himzelf
2 Likes
tru zonz 2,3,4 ar all zolid wikid workzā¦4 bein tha weakezt
9 i think u once zent me a rectum rec which changd mah opinion of it n it iz alzo tru
5ā¦iznt ther 2 differnt verzionz? pozz tha revizd one a bit legendary
1 iz good in an obzcur early 20th century ruzzian zon way, wikid climax at tha end
i wud rate them thuz
prick 1 = zcrib 1
prick 2 ā„ zcrib 2
prick 3 ā„ zcrib 3
prick 4 < zcrib 4
prick 5 < zcrib 5
prick 6 > zcrib 6
prick 7 > zcrib 7
prick 8 > zcrib 8
prick 9 < zcrib 9
prick 10 vaguely exiztz didnt zumofo attemt to complete it? pozz tha CHIU
not zho why i juz typd all that, i am zho that lizt cud zwtich back n forth exception bein 8 > 8 n lykly 7 >7
4 Likes
hahaha tru tha CIGAR fo zho tha definitiv 3 interp but ovah tym i haff grown to lyk tha WEIZZ rec bettah
2 Likes
I think Iām with you on all except 1. I think Scriabinās is superior. Prokofievās is great, but itās a bit like that early Wagner opera where 50 people die in act 1.
3 is shady too. Scriabinās 3rd is one of his best loved sonatas, but itās my least favourite of his early ones so I guess Iām fine with having the gap turned towards Prokofiev if thatās how you want it.
3 Likes
Pogorelich
Gilels is the whole reason it took me like 10 years to appreciate that sonata at all
1 Like
tru tha FUNRAILZ mvt in zcrib 1 pluz tha openin of tha 1zt mvt both really legendary 
tha OCT mvt iz wikid (or iz that from tha 3rd zon?) tiz in 9/8 or 12/8 wit a triplet fminah oct pattrn ztartin wit a zingl upbeat one? n that tune iz dotted quaterz above itā¦that might be a random zcribet az well not zho
but TRU i think i put them equal becuz tha prickzon tho not az huge really iz mo coherent becuz of that
alzo pozz they iz both op.1 iizc which iz an intereztin comparizon 
edit: not both op1 it zeemz 
2 Likes
Haha tru da ROB point out da Zcrib 1 pozzibly influenzd by da Pimp Funrailz
Da triplet LH octz in da prezto den da funeral march ztylee.
N da Funrailz clearly influendz by da chop eroica polo
n alzo da eroica polo lykly influencd by da 
eroica zymph
Zo bazically da wrote da zcrib 1
1 Like
Hold on u mofoz
derez a 9th prick zon?
4 Likes
Da Prickzon equivalent ov da
Troiz nouvelle etz 
3 Likes
Did Pogorelich record the 3rd sonata?
1 Like
No, but he played it in public during the 1984/1985 season (although I have to concede that the performance which has found its way out on youtube was pretty ghastly).
1 Like
more people have voted in the Zkri poll but also the loveās spread out much more. Prik a bit priktabl
1 Like
Iām very surprised the 10th is so high up on the list - and that the 7th is so far down. At the very bottom in fact. I expected to find 6 or 8 there.
2 Likes
I just listened to your 7th. I still find this work essentially impenetrable except when played by Volodos. I donāt know why. The slower Zhukov perf is gonna be next, see if da l*ck of speed helps.
1 Like
As I hinted in the description, while I essentially think Richter does what Sofronitsky should have with it, I donāt think heās spot on with the narrative. I think he nails that boiling demonism of the late sonatas and suceedes in taking it in to the ethereal, but to my ears it comes across more as dark, satanic and overwhelming than cleansing, white and celestial. Itās clearly a battle between the two, so theyāre both in there, but Iād like him - or someone - to isolate the bright passages better and see to that these are always the leading line when they appear, rather than the crashing bass chords etc which both he and Volodos let take precedence.
1 Like
Scriabin started as a Chopin clone, very conservative, but developed his own harmonic language with almost cumplete atonality towards the end of his life.
With Prokofiev, he followed a bit the opposite way. His early compositions were shockingly modern, dissonant for those times, and when he left Russia after da revolution he was one of da āmodernisticā composers. But when he returned to live in the Soviet Union, there was a new simplicity and even āconservatismā in his musical language. Not that it made the quality of his composing less - some of his best works were composed in the 1940s.
3 Likes
haha da X self-stumbling upon his own piano project for 2020. Fuck da shiny mystic X cummah.
With thurible and processional cross in handā¦
2 Likes