I think it also depends on what the specific rep is in each programme and who the pianists are. I don’t need to heard Katsaris play the WTC anymore than I need to hear Brendel play the Norma fantasy. Having said that, there are probably more pianists who would do the Bach recital well than an all opera tranny rectal.
Yes exactly, and also when you realize that abandon, virtuosity, exaggeration - even vulgarness and brutality - have a place in music. I hate it when people introduce all kinds of ritardandos and softening ups of the dynamics in Liszt’s Wilde Jagd to show how “intellectual” they are. If you’re truly an intellectual, you would have worked out that such things have no place there!
This is not a call for dumbing things down or similar, it’s a call for realizing that dry intellectualization is in every bit as poor taste as mindless note spinning.
Very true, I was about to edit it to Liszt paraphrases to compare top notch opera fantasies to top notch P&Fs.
My point is that, while current dogma would consider the Bach program in unusually good taste and the Liszt program in unusually poor taste, I really don’t think one is any worse programming than the other. One is way too academic, the other way too extravagant. Both are too “samey”. And yet all these all-Mozart, all-Bach etc programs go by uncriticized. Aargh!
Yes, I think some of them are just intellectually embarassing themselves. Brendel HR2 he can’t even play the rh scales a tempo and has to “compromise”. Great respect for the composer’s intention there and the less said about his hilarious simplifications at the end the better.
I criticise them. Also playing a whole set of Chopin etudes or Rachmaninoff preludes (or worst, both cough Kultyshev). I’m not sure the last time I heard a really well put together programme. I might have a look through and see if anything stands out.
Although with him I give him credit for being on Liszt’s side. And randomly, one of my favourite Liszt sonatas is the one he did on Vox. However, all copies of that Norma fantasy need to be destroyed. It’s possibly the most unforgiveable cut I’ve ever heard. Second would be Bolet’s in the Prok 2 cadenza.